The Best Sourdough Bread Machine Recipe

The Best Sourdough Bread Machine Recipe

Not all bread machines can make sourdough bread. Most machines are designed to work with dough with commercial yeast and have a short and steady period in which the bread rises.  Sourdough is different, though. It can rise at varying times depending on the culture used. If you want to make a loaf of sourdough bread, make sure your bread machine has a sourdough cycle or an adjustable cycle so you can make changes to the rise time when necessary. If your machine doesn’t have an adjustable option, you may be able to use the machine for the mixing and kneading part of the bread-making process and allow the dough to rise outside of the machine where you have more control. Alternatively, you can play with the timing of the bread machine cycles to try to make it work.

Sourdough Bread Machine Recipe 

Sourdough bread is a little more complicated to make than a regular loaf of white bread but the extra effort is well worth the outcome. Sourdough bread uses something called a starter that is made ahead of time. While some people make it just a day ahead, others feel a full week gives the bread a better taste and texture.

Starter Ingredients

  • ¼-1/3 cup of white flour
  • 1 or 2 tbsp of water
  • Put the flour in a pile and make a small hole. Then, add the water.
  • Mix flour and water slowly by bringing the flour into the middle of the hole. The mixture will go from a paste to a little piece of dough.
  • Knead the dough with your fingers until springy. This will take from 5-8 minutes.
  • Put the dough in a small dish and cover it with a damp towel. Leave it to sit for 2 to 3 days in a warm area.
  • You will know it’s ready when the dough is moist, wrinkled and crusty. It should have small bubbles under the crust and a nice smell.
  • Remove the crust and refresh the remaining portion with twice the original amount of flour and more water so it makes a firm dough.
  • Cover with a wet cloth and put it in a warm place again for 1-2 days.
  • After this time, remove died dough and mix the remainder with about 1 cup of flour.
  • Cover the bowl with a damp cloth and let it sit in a warm area for 8-12 more hours.
  • When finished, the dough will look risen and won’t spring back when poked. 

Now for the Best Sourdough Bread Machine Recipe

Starter prep:

  • The starter needs some work and should be started no later than 12 hours before you start making the bread. Stir the starter and dispose of 1 cup. Then restart the starter with ½ cup water and 1 cup white flour. It must sit between 4-12 hours before its ready for use.
  • Put ¾ cup of the starter aside to use in the recipe and add ½ cp water and 1 cup flour to the remainder. This can sit at room temperature for up to 4 hours until it bubbles then put it covered in the fridge.

Bread Ingredients

As with most bread machine recipes you can make different size loaves. This recipe is for a 1lb loaf.

  • ¾ cp sourdough starter
  • ¼ cp water
  • 1 tbsp butter
  • ¾ tsp. salt
  • 2 cup bread flour
  • 2 tsp sugar
  • 1 ½ tsp bread machine yeast

*This recipe makes the sourdough mild for good sandwich bread. If you want it sourer, take the following steps before putting ingredients in the bread machine:

- Combine water, starter and ½ the flour

- Cover and let it sit for 24 hours. It will get sourer and bubble.

- Combine the mixture that was standing in the bread pan with the rest of the ingredients

When you feel the dough is the right consistency

Photo by Sean Robinson from Pixabay

Once you are ready for the bread pan, put the wet ingredients in then the dry except for the yeast. That can be put in a well in the dry ingredients once they are in the machine as the yeast can’t touch the wet ingredients. If the starter is too thick, you may need to add a little extra water.

Use the sourdough setting if you have one on your machine or use the basic/white bread one. Just be sure to use a medium color setting.

Once the dough has been kneading for a few minutes, check to see what the dough looks like. It should be a smooth ball. If it’s too stiff or gooey, add more water or flour in small bits depending on which it needs. Keep doing this until it gets to the proper consistency but don’t add more than 4 teaspoons of water or flour.

When you feel the dough is the right consistency, close the lid and let the cycle continue until the bread is baked. Once completed, remove the bread from the pan and leave on a wire rack to cool down.

Tips for the Best Sourdough Bread Machine Recipe

  • Save a small bit of the starter. Make sure it’s refrigerated and it lasts for several days. It can be refreshed repeatedly and make more loaves.
  • Let the starter sit for the full 12 hours before using it in the bread machine for a better flavor.
  • If you aren’t using the starter in the fridge for an extended period of time, make sure to take it out every week and feed it with ½ cp of water and 1 cup white flour. Discard a cup first, add the ingredients and then put it back in the fridge. It doesn’t have to sit out to bubble; however, letting it do so gives the next loaf made more flavor.

Leave a Comment: